2023 | 2024 | ||||||
Price: | 2.27 | EPS | 0 | 0 | |||
Shares Out. (in M): | 105 | P/E | 0 | 0 | |||
Market Cap (in $M): | 238 | P/FCF | 0 | 0 | |||
Net Debt (in $M): | 0 | EBIT | 0 | 0 | |||
TEV (in $M): | 168 | TEV/EBIT | 0 | 0 |
Sign up for free guest access to view investment idea with a 45 days delay.
We believe TDUP one of the largest digital thrift shops. TDUP is attractive given ~33% of the market cap is in cash, another ~40% is in unique PP&E, with a valuation (~0.5x sales), largely sunk CAPEX with go forward CAPEX of $3-4 million a year, with guidance of positive EBITDA 2H’23 (close proxy to FCF). We think this interesting business model selling a very large collection of brands at up to -90% off new prices with industry growth tailwinds, w/ real barriers to entry, and a good flow of consignment inventory of roughly 36 million items a year from a highly diversified collection of retail brands. While the company came public at $21 two years ago (rich valuation/early) and with recent 4Q tax loss selling crushed the stock from $4 to $1’s we think the company can work higher over the next year if they hit their guidance. The company in its S-1 was targeting 20% EBITDA margins at scale. While they are a long way off from that now the story makes sense and the signposts are playing out with organic revenue growth, and major RAAS customer wins (effectively outsourcing resale business to TDUP) including Wal-Mart, Target, H&M, and a number of other major retailers. We believe this business has a good demand curve in a recession while solving a pain point for women.
POSH was recently acquired for ~2x sales and was losing money, Etsy paid a crazy valuation for Depop 12x sales, and TDUP is roughly 0.5x sales and guiding for EBITDA + 2H.
We believe TDUP's offering gives women the best solution for cleaning out their closets:
Choices are"
A) Donate (which involves packing up and driving to drop off somewhere and that is it)
B) Sell on Poshmark/eBay, this involves the effort...of taking pictures, managing buyer, and shipping, and might be harder to sell each item one by one
C) TDUP-> Women simply put what they don't want into a box and TDUP does the rest and sends them a check if they sell on a sliding scale. We believe that this proposition really resonates with a lot of women
The perception of TDUP, POSH, TDREAL, RENT, and SFIX is they are all deeply flawed business models for various reasons. While POSH was just acquired for 2x sales which a do-it-yourself marketplace with a 20% take rate. SFIX is nearly the opposite of TDUP, instead of SFIX mailing consumers clothing, consumer mail in their clothes to TDUP the only do-it-for-me scale consignment model. TDUP has sold over 137 million pieces of apparel since 2010 and is handling roughly 100,000 items per day now. The supply side is not a problem here is a quote the CEO from December: “We don't have any problem with sellers. So we spend very little time talking about sellers. We're just trying to get them to not knock down the gates. So sellers is like a true competitive advantage for us.”
We have been impressed with the CEO James Reinhart
TDUP has distribution centers (DC) have gotten progressively more efficient over time and they just moved into version 7. This new DC in Dallas which is four stories and roughly 600,000 square feet and cost over $70 million combined can currently process over $550 million a year and eventually up to $750 million a year. Capacity is roughly 12 million items in inventory if needed. It is interesting to see how much the economics have improved with each new DC. Finally, TDUP has built a database that tracks over 100 million SKU’s from 5,000+ brands on all sorts of proprietary data re: pricing, probability of sale, time to sell, dynamic pricing to turn, and seasonality. TDUP knows that 97% probability a pair of Crocs will sell if listed and 70% chance of Polo selling. Approximately 50% of the apparel sent in is good enough to be listed.
We think TDUP is worth $5-7 over the next 12-24 months or $450-600 million EV if the company can achieve $400-450 million in revenue with 10% EBITDA margins or $.40-.45 cents. The company at scale model is targeting 20% EBITDA margins which are consistent with retail secondhand/consignment shops due to free inventory/reduced working capital/low-cost leadership (good demand curve in a recession due to trade down).
What we think makes TDUP model compelling
Why we believe major retailers joining TDUP RAAS program?
How RAAS works: https://www.raas.thredup.com/how-it-works
Wal-Mart/TDUP -> https://www.walmart.com/browse/5438_1045804_1045806_5393351
Made Well/TDUP-> https://madewellforever.thredup.com/
Pac Sun/TDUP -> https://pacsun.thredup.com/
TDUP powers the RAAS for the following customers -> Wal-Mart, Target, J. Crew, H&M, Gap, Athleta, Torrid, Madewell, Tommy Hilfger, Rent The Runway, Fabletics, Vera Bradley, Kate Spade, Banana Republic, and about 30 others.
There are multiple advantages to Raas: it de-risks the inbound process (partner pays for most of processing), steady supply of higher quality apparel and potential buyer coming through partner sites. Here is their site that tracks all recommerce brands: https://www.recommerce100.com/
What makes TDUP work for the consumer?
Supply Side-> Why Women like TDUP Clean out kit’s->
a) Cleans out their closet for new clothes
b) They believe they are being environmentally friendly
c) Additional use for someone else as well as affirms taste in clothing w a sale
d) Provides cash/found money
All that is required is to go to www.thredup.com print a prepaid label take on likely many boxes lying around the house from Amazon deliveries put whatever apparel they don’t want into the box and ship to Thredup.
TDUP fees:
This link explains how it works for the consumer->
https://www.thredup.com/cleanout/consignment?shop_local=false&state=listed
Since TDUP is the only scale processor, most women that send in clothing actually do not care about earning money from the sale but are most interested in the other attributes of listed above. This is a major positive, as TDUP gets a large source of very low cost inventory that is all based on consignment. The seller is using TDUP as a convenient replacement of dropping bag full of clothes at Goodwill.
Demand side-> Diversified collection of brands at up to -90% off new prices
Why we like TDUP:
We believe in a recession there will be a good demand curve for brand names at up to -90% off new prices, a high turning diversified collection of brands from A-Z, solves a pain-point, free inventory w/ consignment model take rate, and with real barriers to entry. We also believe that the last 6-9 months in retail might be one of the most aggressive environments for discounting over the last several decades (nearly every retailer had 1.5-2x normalized inventory given supply chain backlog, then Russia/Ukraine blew everything up and consumer paralyzed inflation, then fire sale discounting).
Here is a link to their database of brands/pricing/inventory over 1000-> https://www.thredup.com/brands
This was built out and opened in 2022....
Above: ”The state-of-the-art facility is designed to be thredUP’s first four-level distribution center and upon completion will store as many as 10 million items – more than doubling the company’s total capacity to 16.5 million items across its network. thredUP plans to invest $70 million in capital for the new distribution center.” -Source https://www.idilogistics.com/press_release/idi-logistics-pre-leases-construction-dallas-area-warehouse-thredup/
Management has mentioned no new capex in capacity needed till revenue >>$500mm. At $500mm of revenue, assuming flattish fixed costs, GP = ~$360mm (72%GM, not a stretched goal as consignment % of revenue mix will increase vs product) and EBITDA ~$40-50mm|8-10%. From a unit perspective, 10mn orders (up from 6.5mn in FY22, growth has been 25-35% historically), AOV = ~$50 (in line historically), GP/order = $36, Contribution Margin/order = $16 (implies CM% = 32%, CM has been in the ~$12-17+ range over last few yrs). With $120mm of fixed costs (flattish to FY2022), EBITDA = ~$40mm. There is upside to the $40mm given no/little improvements in CM% which should materialize as the new Dallas DC is now up and running (lower unit processing costs). If using company estimates of 37% CM%, EBITDA = $65mm. With historical growth rates, should hit ~$500mm of revenue in ~FY25
A key risk for any digital marketplace: Does the value proposition resonate for BOTH the supply side and demand side? To date, TDUP has tapped into a very significant source of supply without much effort. They will need to continue to scale the demand side. To this point, 80% of customers are repeat buyers and make three purchases per year. It is also encouraging that the growth RAAS adds both new buyers and sellers and liquidity to TDUP marketplace. If repeat purchases, supply slows, or customer acquisition increases it would obviously hurt TDUP.
DISCLAIMER: This does not constitute a recommendation to buy or sell this stock. We own shares of the company, and we may buy shares or sell shares at any time.
2H EBITDA profitability
More RAAS wins...last week added H&M
10% organic revenue growth in a challenging retail world is not a bad result
CAPEX is largely sunk costs and will decline materially
Strong balance sheet with currently $70 million in cash
Low valuation of 0.5x sales
Hard to replicate assets-> $70-100 million DC, supply side 100K new items a day/6.5 million buyers annually
show sort by |
Are you sure you want to close this position THREDUP INC?
By closing position, I’m notifying VIC Members that at today’s market price, I no longer am recommending this position.
Are you sure you want to Flag this idea THREDUP INC for removal?
Flagging an idea indicates that the idea does not meet the standards of the club and you believe it should be removed from the site. Once a threshold has been reached the idea will be removed.
You currently do not have message posting privilages, there are 1 way you can get the privilage.
Apply for or reactivate your full membership
You can apply for full membership by submitting an investment idea of your own. Or if you are in reactivation status, you need to reactivate your full membership.
What is wrong with message, "".