Description
Summary
I recommend a long position in Sykes Enterprises, a Business Process Outsourcing (BPO) or call-center business. Having recently completed the cash and stock acquisition of ICT Group, Sykes is poised to accelerate earnings growth and is trading at around 7x estimated Q4 2010 run-rate earnings and 3x EBITDA. With a net cash balance sheet and a long track record of organic growth and profitability, Sykes is a quality operator now trading at a highly attractive valuation (after falling 50% from its 52 week high). There is nothing too complicated about the situation, just a growth company that has had a minor stumble and has fallen into deep value territory due to market over-reaction. SYKE was previously written up on VIC, but none more recently than 4 years ago. Paddy had a couple of great calls going long at 4x EBITDA and short at 10x EBITDA 2 years later.
Industry
The growth of the call center industry has been driven by the combination of improved telephony equipment and infrastructure, and customers' willingness to outsource non-core functions such as call centers in their drive to increase both profits and service levels. While many think of India as the location of choice for call centers, the industry is actually much more global and diversified. Sykes, for example, operates 70 call centers in 24 countries, with over 50,000 employees. Call center companies are paid in one of three ways: time and materials, per call, or per minute. Contracts typically include bonuses and penalties based upon various service level metrics that are closely monitored (such as average hold time or customer feedback data).
Expected Industry Trends
- Continued modest industry growth, as less than 30% of the potential market is currently outsourced. Sykes cites an industry study predicting a 2.4% topline CAGR through 2013.
- Continued move from servicing US clients onshore to offshore, in an effort to reduce costs.
- Continued consolidation, as large clients increasingly prefer vendors with ability to service accounts from variety of geographic locations. Also, vendors such as Sykes need to avoid significant client concentration in order to reduce risk and enhance bargaining position.
- Pricing. I expect flattish pricing on shore, slightly pressured pricing offshore as the currently higher margins likely will be competed lower over the long term, and a negative mix impact to pricing (as continued offshoring leads to lower revenues per minute).
Company Overview
- Sykes was founded in 1977, began focusing on the call center business in the early 1990s, and has been public since 1996.
- Pro forma for the ICT acquisition this year, Sykes' 2009 revenues were around $1.25 billion and 2009 EBITDA was $160 million (including estimated cost synergies of $24 million).
- Sykes has one large client (AT&T at around 14% of revenues), beyond that client customer concentration is minimal (next largest is 4%). The ATT business is comprised of 3 separate programs, lessening the concentration risk.
- Top verticals include Communications (36%), Technology (22%) and Financial Services (21%).
- Focus on inbound customer service calls (97%) which are more stable than outbound telemarketing (3%).
- 85% of business is voice, with small amounts of email and chat support.
- 80% of business supports services, rather than products (product-based call demand tends to be lumpier as it is driven by new product sales, whereas call demand for services such as credit cards tends to be more stable).
- Sykes determines its business segments based upon the location of the customer, rather than the "delivery location". I believe this is done in order to purposely obscure offshore margins for competitive reasons. In general, the offshore segment is likely to have materially higher margins than onshore.
- Acquired the publicly-traded ICT Group for $225 million in a 50% cash/50% stock deal (stock issued much higher at $24 per SYKE share). This represented 6.7x 2009 EBITDA of $33mm and 3.9x 2009 EBITDA if adjusted for $24mm of cost synergies. The acquisition appears to be a good fit based on minimal client overlap, strong market share of the financial services vertical, and the benefits of additional scale.
Financials
- 13% topline organic CAGR since 2004. Over half of the growth was from new program wins from existing customers (as opposed to new customers).
- Stable gross margins in the 32-33% range. The stability of gross margins indicates that although pricing pressure exists, it has been very manageable historically.
- Operating margins gradually expanding from the 5% range to the 8-9% range over the past 5 years, as Sykes was able to leverage its G&A costs. EBITDA margins have expanded similarly, and were 12% in 2009.
- ROEs in the 10-16% range, despite a conservative balance sheet (net cash) and the near-term margin hits from the constant launch of new facilities for growth.
- Strong Free Cash Flow. Total capex (including significant growth capex as the topline almost doubled from 2004 to 2009), has averaged around 35% of EBITDA. Maintenance capex is estimated to be around half of total capex, so Sykes generates good Free Cash Flow. In 2010, Sykes should generate around $140mm of EBITDA (including ICT for 11 months), and has estimated maintenance capex of $25mm (18% of EBITDA) and growth capex of $20mm.
|
2009 |
2008 |
2007 |
2006 |
2005 |
2004 |
Summary Financials |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Sales/Revenue |
846.0 |
819.2 |
710.1 |
574.2 |
494.9 |
466.7 |
Gross Income |
276.8 |
267.1 |
233.6 |
183.9 |
159.4 |
135.9 |
EBIT |
72.0 |
66.0 |
51.5 |
31.9 |
24.8 |
0.9 |
EBITDA |
100.4 |
94.0 |
76.8 |
56.7 |
50.8 |
31.1 |
Capital Expenditures |
30.3 |
34.7 |
31.5 |
19.4 |
9.9 |
25.7 |
EPS (recurring) |
1.116 |
1.490 |
0.979 |
1.060 |
0.603 |
0.190 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Margins & Ratios |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Gross Margin |
32.7% |
32.6% |
32.9% |
32.0% |
32.2% |
29.1% |
EBIT Margin |
8.5% |
8.1% |
7.3% |
5.6% |
5.0% |
0.2% |
EBITDA Margin |
11.9% |
11.5% |
10.8% |
9.9% |
10.3% |
6.7% |
Return on Equity (ROE) |
10.4% |
16.2% |
12.1% |
16.4% |
10.7% |
5.3% |
Valuation
- $13.95 stock price x 47 million shares = $656 equity market cap. $243mm cash, $75mm term loan, so $168mm of net cash. Enterprise value is $488mm. Much of Sykes' cash is held overseas, and would be subject to taxation if repatriated. Sykes appears to be waiting for potential repatriation holidays, and that is why it has a funded term loan despite the large cash balance. One could penalize Sykes' valuation by taxing the cash balance, but that company is so cheap that it would not impact the situation greatly.
- P/E Multiples are 10x 2010 consensus EPS of $1.43 and 7x Q4 estimated run-rate of $2.00 EPS.
- EBITDA multiples are 3.0x the 2009 pro forma number with cost synergies.
- $79mm of Free Cash Flow, equating to a 12% FCF yield (FCF calculated as after-tax net income + DD&A less maintenance capex).
- Industry valuation has typically been 6-9x EBITDA (with M&A occurring at high end of range) and 12-16x EPS. For your reference, Sykes includes historical deal multiples and current trading multiples in the appendix of its investor presentation. On an EBITDA basis, Sykes is trading at approximately half the low end of the M&A comp multiples.
Risks/Issues/Why Opportunity Exists
- Q1 Earnings Announcement. The stock is down around 35% since Q1 earnings were announced. There were several issues mentioned.
1. Q1 EPS light due primarily to higher tax rate.
2. Europe margins down meaningfully due to weak demand in the technology vertical. Also, given European labor laws, it takes more time to flex the labor force accordingly, leading to margin compression. This underscored investor concerns about European economic growth going forward, and the impact on Sykes (less than 1/3 of profits).
3. Reduced revenue guidance, apparently due to weakness at ICT telecom clients. I believe this is a result of mild disappointment with the status of two acquired clients, and my research indicates it does not represent broad dissatisfaction with ICT among their customer base. The reality is that when you buy a public company, you often get limited access to their customers, and the target can misrepresent the state of affairs with no real consequences.
- Long-term Offshore Margin Compression. I am not sure that the market is concerned about this at the moment, but I believe this is a long term risk factor. I also believe that Sykes' track record indicates it should be manageable.
- Utilization Rates Low. Sykes is currently at a utilization rate of around 72%, as opposed to a target rate of 85%. However, with a strong sales pipeline and a proven ability to win new business, this could be viewed as more of an opportunity (obviously higher utilization rates would increase margins).
- ICT Risk. Clearly ICT was the largest acquisition in Sykes' history, and the only one they have done in years. In terms of integration risk, I believe that system and technology risk is actually minimal (this is really not a technology or system driven business). The greater risks may be unknown customer losses, such as the shortfalls Sykes discovered shortly after purchase. I take some comfort from the fact that Sykes has now owned ICT for several months, has apparently met with all major customers, and has not announced any additional issues. Sykes also is a strong operator that seems quite analytical, providing some additional comfort.
- Uncertain Performance in a Double-Dip Recession Scenario. When call volumes fall, some customers that are only partially outsourced can keep more volume in-house to fill their own centers, thereby exacerbating the impact on outsourced providers. Also, there is some fear that competitors would compete more aggressively on price if utilizations fell in another recession.
Is This a Good Business? I think Sykes is an above average operator in an average business. I believe that the historical and projected industry growth, the expanding profit margins, and the respectable ROEs despite the drag of a conservative balance sheet and growth-related expenses, indicate that this is not a bad business. While one may assume that this is a purely price-driven service, the reality is that customers don't switch vendors frequently or easily. Customers certainly care about price, but also care about service excellence and execution.
Management. The CEO is Charles Sykes, who is the son of the founder John Sykes. Charles has worked at the company since 1986, has been CEO since 2004, and I consider him to be a strong operator based upon his analytical answers to conference call questions and his company's track record of execution. Charles' stock holdings are less than 1%, but his father continues to own approximately 13% of the company which presumably aligns his interest.
Catalyst
SYKE performs well and generates expected Q4 run-rate earnings, highlighting extreme valuation.
SYKE pays down $75mm term loan and/or repurchases shares.