Pages Jaunes is a directories business disguised as an Internet company. Global ad spending is falling, yet PAJ FP believes itself to be insulated given the current state of the French economy and its growing internet division. Despite this, earnings fell ~10% in 2007 and I anticipate this to get worse in 2008 and beyond.
Secular/Cyclical Challenges: Similar to other yellow pages businesses worldwide, PAJ FP is a secularly and cyclically challenged business facing a significant slowdown in its core print directory business, while pinning its hopes on its internet business (32% of revs)
Leverage: PAJ FP is highly levered @ ~4x EBITDA and pays 100% of its FCF out as dividends – no debt paydown without a dividend cut; FCF does not cover the dividend
Valuation: PAJ FP is trading @ ~10x EBITDA, or ~40% higher than its global peers @ ~7.5x
PE Overhang: KKR, Goldman Sachs (54.7%) and employees (0.5%) control PAJ FP; PE firms ‘confident’ of ability to refinance
Bottom Line: I believe PAJ FP is has at least 50% downside from current levels, faces a dividend cut and should trade inline with global peers
Description
PAJ FP publishes directories (general public/business), provide online services and aids in direct marketing
Online services include website creation, hosting and business ad services
PAJ FP sells business and consumer databases for multi-channel direct marketing campaigns using mail, telephone, SMS or emails
Publication of directories includes listings of private and business telephone subs for each admin department
Localization services include route planning services and databases of photographs of major cities
PAJ FP operates in France, Spain, Belgium and Luxembourg
History: Public LBO
KKR/Goldman Sachs purchased a controlling stake in PAJ FP from France Telecom (FTE FP) in mid-2006
KKR/Goldman Sachs re-levered PAJ FP with a massive debtload and paid themselves a ‘special’ one-time dividend of €9/share in 2007 – assuming FCF would finance 100% dividend policy and the massive debtload – essentially a public LBO
PAJ FP sold a minority stake in its PagesJaunes Petites Announces division (online classified ads) to M6 Metropole Television (€2.1B public broadcast company) in 2007
Bottom Line: PAJ FP has no margin of safety as there is no room to de-leverage given the 100% dividend policy and relies on the sponsor’s ability to refinance the debtload – unlikely in a recession scenario, or in the face of mounting competition from online players
Other
Negative Shareholder Equity: Pre-special dividend, PAJ FP had €407mm shareholders’ equity. Post-dividend – equity turned negative to -€2.7B. Given PAJ FP’s dividend policy, expect shareholders’ equity to continue to trend lower until debt is paid off – either refinance, raise equity or sell assets
PAJ FP’s debt is 82% hedged, but the swap and collar hedges will lift in Dec. 2011
Organic Growth: Other global yellow pages companies in US/UK face slowing organic revenue growth – 1-3% at best vs. 5% for PAJ FP, though all face similar headwinds: economic slowdown, limited visibility, secular challenges, Internet competition and high financial leverage
PAJ FP is reducing its prices by 20% for selected areas in France for ads in its print directories
PAJ FP’s Internet business has a ~23% 5 year CAGR and is ~32% of total revenues; PAJ FP expects Internet to be >40% of revenues in 2008
Seat Pagine Gialle (PG IM) issued a profit warning yesterday, blaming the increasing prominence of Internet and greater competition from GOOG. In response, PAJ FP takes the approach France is different
To facilitate its transformation to an Internet company, PAJ FP is lowering the directory prices in large cities (Paris, Lyon and Marseille) and by raising Internet prices
(€mm), except per share data
€ m
$
Price (4/08/08)
€ 12.17
$19.19
FD Shares O/S (mm)
284.8
284.8
Market Cap (mm)
€ 3,466
$5,466
Free Float (45%)
€ 1,553
$2,449
Net Debt (mm)
€ 1,884
$2,971
EV (mm)
€ 5,350
$8,437
Debt/Mkt Cap
54.4%
FX ($/€)
$1.5770
52 week HI
€ 17.24
-29.4%
52 week LO
€ 10.02
+21.5%
YTD Performance
€ 13.71
-11.2%
(€mm)
2006
2007
2008E
Sales
1,093.3
1,158.3
1,210.8
EBITDA
460.9
503.6
481.2
Net Income
296.9
269.6
216.9
Net Income Margin
27.2%
23.3%
17.9%
EBITDA Margin
42.2%
43.5%
39.7%
Return on Assets
21.6%
31.7%
23.0%
Net Debt/EBITDA
4.1 x
3.7 x
3.9 x
Shareholders' Equity
(2,060.6)
(2,073.3)
(2,073.3)
Total Assets
850.2
944.1
944.1
Net Debt
1,884.1
1,884.0
1,884.0
Catalysts
Recession/Falling ARPA: Despite growing the number of advertisers, ARPU is falling. In a recession/further economic slowdown in Europe – this trend exacerbates. PAJ FP has responded by increasing Internet ad prices while decreasing the number of print ads – lowering print ARPU/revenues
Dividend Cut: PAJ FP cannot continue paying out 100% FCF as dividends in the current economic environment (€303mm in dividends in ’07 vs. €267mm ’07 FCF) – in all likelihood, the dividend will be cut. However, if the credit/economic environment gets better – its possible they can avoid a cut
Earnings Downgrades: I would expect Analysts have yet to similarly downgrade PagesJaunes. PagesJaunes earnings expectations and seem to be accepting the company’s word at hand. This may lead to future surprise earnings downgrades, just as happened in the US and UK
Debt Refinancing?: PE sponsors did not anticipate a credit crunch when they structured its credit hedges in 2006 (expiring 2011 with debt due in late 2013). If current conditions persist, its highly unlikely PAJ FP can refinance the debt. It’s also likely the current dividend will need to be cut in order to pay down debt in the event of covenant violations
Investors Day (4/30/08): PAJ FP is expected to highlight its new pricing strategy and focus on its Internet initiatives. Inevitably, PAJ FP will have to address economic slowdown issues as well and its effect on business
France Telecom Non-Compete: FTE FP sold its 54% controlling stake to KKR/Goldman Sachs in mid-2006 for €13/sh. FTE FP’s non-compete clause ends in 2010. While its unclear FTE FP will re-enter the business, it’s possible especially if PAJ FP is reeling. Another possibility is FTE FP funding a startup competitor
Valuation/Relative Performance
PAJ FP is trading at ~10x ’08 EBITDA – significantly higher than its comps at ~7.5x (YELL LN, IAR, RHD, ENRO SS, PG IM)
PAJ FP pays out 100% of FCF as dividends vs. industry average of ~37%
Leverage is ~4x EBITDA vs. industry average ~5x
PAJ FP has fallen ~21% over the past year vs. industry average >70% decline
Newspaper stocks are trading ~6-7x EBITDA – on a comparative basis, PAJ FP would trade ~€4-6/share
Catalyst
1) Recession/Falling ARPA; 2) Dividend Cut; 3) Earnings Downgrades; 4) Debt Refinancing?; 5) Investors Day (4/30/08); 6) France Telecom Non-Compete
Are you sure you want to close this position PagesJaunes Groupe?
By closing position, I’m notifying VIC Members that at today’s market price, I no longer am recommending this position.
Flag PagesJaunes Groupe for Removal
Are you sure you want to Flag this idea PagesJaunes Groupe for removal?
Flagging an idea indicates that the idea does not meet the standards of the club and you believe it should be removed from the site. Once a threshold has been reached the idea will be removed.
You Cannot Submit Message ... Yet
You currently do not have message posting privilages, there are
1 way you can get the privilage.
You can apply for full membership by submitting an investment idea of your own. Or if you are in reactivation status, you need to reactivate your full membership.