2023 | 2024 | ||||||
Price: | 0.57 | EPS | 0.07 | 0 | |||
Shares Out. (in M): | 244 | P/E | 6.0 | 0 | |||
Market Cap (in $M): | 139 | P/FCF | 6.0 | 0 | |||
Net Debt (in $M): | 0 | EBIT | 25 | 0 | |||
TEV (in $M): | 108 | TEV/EBIT | 4.4 | 0 |
Sign up for free guest access to view investment idea with a 45 days delay.
Executive Summary
Overview
Duratec is an Australian-listed micro-cap company that carries a market capitalization of AUD $139MM and an enterprise value of AUD $93MM. Duratec is headquartered in Western Australia and is in the business of providing maintenance services to owners of large infrastructure assets such as bridges, wharves, ports, pipelines, processing plants, and high-rise buildings in both the public and private sectors.
The company’s successful leveraging of human capital and technology has helped it to earn consistent returns on capital of 30%+ which has allowed Duratec to build considerable economic value while growing its revenues and profits at high rates over the past 12 years. Management firmly believes this trend will continue, most recently announcing guidance at its November 2022 AGM for FY23 (ending June 2023) of EBITDA between $32-35MM and by my estimate net income of ~$18MM, implying a FY23E P/E of 6.0x net of excess cash and an estimated EV/EBIT of 4.4x.
Although a valuation discount of this size for a quality company may appear too good to be true, I believe Duratec is currently experiencing a combination of a classic lack of discovery, particularly by non-Australian investors, and a misperception as a high risk E&C company. Considering the company’s competitive strengths, demonstrated history of success, skilled and aligned senior management, sizable growth opportunity ahead, and exceptionally low valuation, I expect there is a strong probability of significant share price appreciation from here over the intermediate-term and possibly as soon as February when Duratec reports its 1H 2023 half-year results that should be a marked improvement YoY.
Introduction to Duratec
Duratec was founded in 2010 by its top executives Phil Harcourt, Chris Oates, and Deane Diprose who, before founding Duratec, had been working together for over 15 years at a company called Savcor. There, they worked in various roles within the company’s infrastructure maintenance division, until a series of poor strategic decisions by the company’s CEO (far removed from Phil, Chris, and Deane) placed Savcor’s future in jeopardy. Phil, Chris, and Deane saw an opportunity to band together and form their own asset remediation firm from scratch, and in 2010 left Savcor to form Duratec.
(Source: Duratec, FY22 Results Presentation)
Seed capital from entrepreneur Jim Giumelli of Ertech, key hires of former colleagues from Savcor in the company’s early years, and most importantly top management’s navigation of steady contract wins and client relationship-building have all been key contributors to Duratec’s revenue growth CAGR of 32% over the 12 years since its founding. This growth was also achieved almost entirely organically, with a total of just $500,000 spent on strategic acquisitions over that span. Duratec listed through IPO in December 2020.
Duratec’s Business Model
Every year in Australia, tens or hundreds of billions of dollars in capital expenditures are spent on new infrastructure assets across a wide variety of industries. Government departments need to build new military bases and airports, mining companies need to build new processing plants and wharves, and public and private interests need to construct new buildings, as several examples.
Though, once this infrastructure is built, what steps do asset owners need to take to enable their infrastructure to function for the 10-70 years for which they are intended to last? The answer is infrastructure maintenance and remediation, for which each year asset owners spend an average of 4-5% of their asset’s value. To get this work done, the asset owners need to bring in remediation specialists, which is where firms such as Duratec step in.
Duratec is an asset remediation contractor that specializes in steel and concrete remediation for infrastructure assets across a handful of industries. Through its roster of over 800 project staff and engineers, Duratec provides end-to-end service for its clients who are seeking a reliable asset remediation specialist to repair their infrastructure and for clients who also may be seeking diagnoses of asset condition.
The company typically wins its work in one of three ways:
Once Duratec wins a contract or ECI/MSA work, it either self-performs the remediation work through its team of project staff and engineers or subcontracts the work out to another remediation contractor. In practice, the only work Duratec tends to subcontract out is highly specialized aspects of projects (electrical, air conditioning, etc.) for its defense segment jobs in which Duratec does not has the expertise to perform the tasks themselves. For all other segments including mining, industrial, and buildings & facades, Duratec almost always self-performs its remediation work, which also earns higher gross margin than subcontracted work as it eliminates the cost layer of subcontractor charges.
The different industries for which Duratec performs its asset remediation work can be broken down into four major segments:
In October 2022, Duratec completed an acquisition (its first ever material acquisition) of an oil & gas contractor Wilson’s Pipe Fabrication (“Wilson’s”). Duratec paid $9MM for Wilson’s, which generated $3MM in TTM EBIT and is expected to generate $4MM in FY23 EBIT. The rationale for the acquisition, which unlocks an additional $5B annual TAM in oil & gas infrastructure maintenance work, was because of Duratec’s assertion that within any given vertical, clients are far more willing to work with contractors with whom they have good existing relationships and/or who have vertical-specific experience. Acquiring Wilson’s saves Duratec many years of attempting to break into the oil & gas vertical which would have yielded no guarantee of success.
Duratec’s historical revenues and gross profits are illustrated by segment in the table below:
(Source: Duratec Limited, Financial Statements)
As visible above, revenue by segment can be volatile YoY and revenue & margins fluctuated quite a bit in FY21 and FY22, both of which are trends worth touching upon.
First, while defense work is quite stable and predictable YoY, most other segments are less predictable and can be prone to large revenue swings YoY because of the timing of larger contracts. However, these one-off swings eventually resemble direction over time, and thanks to Duratec’s industry diversification total aggregate revenue and gross profit are far less volatile YoY than the most volatile individual segment(s).
Second, COVID lockdowns significantly impacted Duratec’s FY 2021 (fiscal year ends June 30) and 1H 2022 operations as certain clients, including the DoD, delayed ongoing projects which had the effect of delaying revenue while incurring ongoing personnel expenses. The post-lockdown 2H 2022 period better reflects a return to normal operations and results. Several factors, including an unusually high input cost price of steel, cost inflation, and an inverse relationship between project size and gross margin contributed to the gross margin decline in FY 2022.
Lastly, as mentioned, management recently guided to FY23 revenue of between $420-460MM or +35-48% YoY and EBITDA of $32-35MM or +66-81% YoY, and has stated that it believes growth opportunities across the board should continue “for years to come.”
Why Duratec Isn’t Your Typical Engineering & Construction (E&C) Business
Although Duratec has demonstrated consistent success to date, one source of misunderstanding that may exist to prospective investors is that at its surface it looks like a typical E&C company, a connotation which carries with it thoughts of high risk and boom-bust dynamics. However, I have found that Duratec is not your typical E&C business for several key reasons, detailed below. Rather, Duratec’s risk profile is in my view meaningfully lower than that of its E&C peers, and ultimately implies Duratec to be a higher quality company than most of its peers.
Why E&C Businesses Carry a Poor Reputation and Why Duratec is Different
History has shown that the base rate of success for E&C businesses over full cycles and long time horizons can be low. This are several reasons that explain this:
Why Duratec is Different: Duratec’s work consisting of almost entirely asset maintenance projects removes from its risk profile what is arguably the biggest risk that E&C firms face. Construction projects all else equal are usually more complex, involve more input costs, and occur over longer time horizons than remediation projects. While this lowers the gross margin ceiling for remediation projects if things go according to plan, it also raises the floor if things go wrong.
Why Duratec is Different: Given almost 100% of Duratec’s work is strictly asset remediation, maintenance CapEx even in cyclical industries is far more stable in both boom and bust periods, providing Duratec with a significantly less volatile and more predictable stream of future earnings. In addition, as of 1H 2022, 40% of Duratec’s gross profit is derived from the Department of Defense which publishes a 10-year forward budget that shows fully visible, stable, and growing asset maintenance CapEx spend, of which Duratec should be a beneficiary (see TAM: Defense for further discussion). Duratec expects DoD projects to continue to be a meaningful part of its future work.
Aside from construction being their primary or sole business operation of these three firms, each company’s cause for bankruptcy was also tied to irresponsibly large projects that failed: Forge Group’s top two projects comprised 55% of its order book and both ran into issues in 2014; Decmil’s largest construction contract comprised 45% of its order book and ran into trouble in 2019; and Clough’s two biggest projects summed to almost double the size of its order book which incurred cost overruns and aided in the company’s demise in 2022.
Why Duratec is Different: Duratec’s top 5 projects comprise roughly 45-50% of its order book which, while still offering a degree of risk, is more responsible than the risk management of its failed peers and below the common industry concentration of 60-70%. To mitigate the company’s risk exposure to its largest projects, top management spends a disproportionate amount of its time overseeing the company’s largest projects. Duratec’s management also possesses an excellent track record of project success. In its 26 year history of working together at Savcor and Duratec, top management has never experienced a major project failure as defined as one where the client has triggered its bank guarantee, suggesting management’s long-term focus on risk mitigation.
Why Duratec is Different: Phil, Chris, and Deane are each co-founders of Duratec, each owning 11% of the business’s outstanding shares. As the inverse of risk enhancement, I view their large share ownerships as an enhanced positive attribute with respect to Duratec. Management has demonstrated over time to be just as concerned about stability in profits as they have been about growth in profits. Furthermore, their statements and actions suggest that they are ambitious for the company, not just for themselves, and that they understand this is the far more sensible path to long-term success.
Competitive Advantages and Barriers to Entry
In addition to the reduction or absence of risk compared to your typical E&C firm, Duratec also appears to be in possession of a key competitive advantage that differentiates it from its asset remediation peers, barriers to entry that will likely make it difficult for new entrants to replicate Duratec’s success, and a handful of competitive strengths that should improve its probability of continued success.
MEnD is run by Liam Holloway, an engineer who holds a PhD in corrosion and concrete durability and who also used to work alongside Duratec’s top management during their Savcor days. Like Duratec’s top managers, Liam also left Savcor to form his own company MEnD, and in 2017 Duratec acquired MEnD to work together once again.
By Duratec’s admission, MEnD adds a great deal of value to Duratec. It acts as a strong lead generator of clients by providing best-in-class asset assessment services to potential clients and boasts an 80% conversion rate of MEnD clients becoming Duratec clients where Duratec performs the remediation work detailed by MEnD. According to Duratec, for every $1 of consulting work MEnD performs for a client, Duratec earns $25 in project revenue and at higher margins than non-MEnD assessed projects. MEnD’s services also improve Duratec’s existing client retention rates who find MEnD’s services valuable. Lastly, MEnD’s comprehensive 3D assessments reduce risk for both Duratec and the client because the comprehensive asset assessment helps to minimize unforeseen project challenges that might otherwise lead to cost overruns, time delays, and more serious potential issues.
Perhaps MEnD’s importance to Duratec is best articulated by top management:
“Ultimately, this is what sets us apart. It's what makes us successful, what gives us margin and reputation. And it's also the hardest thing to replicate by any other contractor by a longshot, to be able to come fly drones and our 3D modeling. Some companies can fly drones, some companies can probably assess concrete, and some companies may be able to fix it. But to bring all of those things together and get on site for the bigger companies. To me, there's just nobody that can do it. For somebody to catch up in that space, I think would take years.” – Executive Director at Duratec
In his book Good to Great, Jim Collins coined the term Technological Accelerator: “The transformation from good to great does not happen with a pioneering technology but by realizing the right technology and becoming a pioneer in the application of that technology.” Duratec, whose namesake was formed as the combination of the words “Duratec” and “Technology,” appears to have been a pioneer in the application of this technology and its managers plan to do everything they can to press this advantage and remain a technological leader.
DDR Joint Venture
Duratec, in addition to its main business also owns a 49% stake in a Dundee Rock (“DDR”) JV. DDR was formed in 2017 by Duratec and its 51% equity and business partner of aboriginal descent to be an asset remediation services contractor, similar to Duratec, with the main difference being that DDR competes for maintenance contract work exclusively available to businesses that are aboriginal owned. In Australia, providing work and training opportunities to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples is a Government mandate. So far, the Government has started awarding these exclusive contracts through the Department of Defense, which Duratec’s management believes will soon extend to other public Departments to which DDR believes it can expand its services and win additional project streams.
Since inception, DDR has steadily won work and has grown quite rapidly:
(Source: Duratec Limited, FY22 Results Presentation)
DDR most recently delivered a remarkable 19% EBIT margin vs. low-mid single digits for Duratec as a result of strong pricing power due to low competition and also due to cost savings by having Duratec provide support for various back office functions (e.g. IT, admin, payroll, accounting), procure insurance at favorable rates, and assist with other central tasks. Furthermore, DDR’s position as a first mover in competing for these Government-mandated Aboriginal contracts has allowed it to attract among the best of the limited talent pool of Aboriginal engineers. This should make it more difficult for new entrants to build quality businesses. Management expects margins to compress over time as competition increases, but is confident that DDR’s revenue and profit contribution should continue to increase going forward.
Total Addressable Market Opportunity
Duratec’s domestic TAM is approximately $46B of annual infrastructure maintenance spend across the company’s industry segments. At a midpoint of $440MM expected FY23 revenue, Duratec currently captures <1% of its TAM, whereas segment-specific market share leaders regularly capture 5-10% or more of each segment’s market share. Long-term, capturing 5-10% market share within each of its industry segments would imply Duratec’s potential mature revenue to be $2.3-4.6B or 5-10x FY23E sales.
TAM: Defense
The Department of Defense, which issues a 10-year forward looking infrastructure budget, has estimated $12.6B in 2020-21 and $23.8B in 2029-30 for annual remediation spend.
(Source: Duratec Limited, IPO Prospectus)
(Source: Duratec Limited, IPO Prospectus)
TAM: Mining
The strong level of industry CapEx spend from 2011 to 2015 has led to a subsequent increase in maintenance CapEx spend. Annual industry maintenance spend is expected to continue to grow from $6.6B in FY20 to reach approximately $7.4B by FY24.
(Source: Duratec Limited, IPO Prospectus)
TAM: Industrial
Through the forecast period, annual industrial maintenance spend is expected to grow from $24.6B in FY20 to $27.7B in FY24. Duratec performs work in the resources & heavy industry and road bridge & tunnel sub-sectors which comprise 49.5% within the total industrial spend.
(Source: Duratec Limited, IPO Prospectus)
TAM: Buildings & Façade
Currently annual industry spend on facilities management services is approximately $10.6B, growing to approximately $11.2B by FY25. The two largest contributors to facilities management revenue in Australia are major and minor maintenance services, which comprise 41.3% and are markets serviced by Duratec.
(Source: Duratec Limited, IPO Prospectus)
TAM: Oil & Gas
Annual maintenance spend within Australia’s oil & gas industry is expected to total approximately $5B from FY23 through FY27.
(Source: Monadelphous Group, 2022 AGM Presentation)
TAM: Wastewater
Australia spends an estimated AUD $8.6B each year on water and wastewater treatment services. Direct capital purchases and equipment maintenance account for 20% of total spending.
Valuation
At AUD $0.57/share we find Duratec’s shares to be remarkably undervalued which I estimate can currently be bought at a FY23E P/E of 6.0x net of excess cash while delivering a dividend yield of 6.5%. After taking into account adjustments to arrive at an estimate of Owner’s Earnings, I believe the company’s true earnings power is stronger than its IFRS figures suggest, implying a FY23E Owner’s Earnings yield of 21%.
On a relative basis, Duratec is also the lowest valued among its peer group by a wide margin despite being an arguably higher quality business and anticipating strong double digit growth for the foreseeable future.
Estimating Owner’s Earnings
Taking management’s recent guidance for the fiscal year ending June 30, 2023 as a starting point, we can reasonably expect Duratec to generate FY23 EBITDA of AUD $33.5MM which includes its JV income and dividends from DDR. After subtracting depreciation, interest expense, and taxes, we arrive at an estimated net income of approximately AUD $18.1MM.
In estimating Owner’s Earnings, net income likely understates Owner’s Earnings because the accounting depreciation schedule of Duratec’s vehicles and equipment occurs faster than the company’s economic useful lives of these assets. For instance, vehicles, which consist of the majority of Duratec’s depreciable assets, are depreciated over a period 5 years when in practice they are useful for an average of 10 years. Therefore, approximating maintenance CapEx at ~50% of our FY23E depreciation expense estimate of $8.8MM yields a FY23E Owner’s Earnings estimate of $22.5MM.
Although excluded from this analysis, Owner’s Earnings is likely even further understated because of upfront SG&A growth investments that Duratec is continually making in new local offices across the country. These local offices can take years to scale up their local order books and reach mature margins. However, given this number is hard to quantify, I’ve excluded it from this calculation.
Duratec’s market cap today stands at AUD $139MM. As of FY 2022, the company held $58MM of cash and $12MM in equipment financing, or a net cash position of $46MM. Management feels comfortable holding a minimum of $15MM of net cash at any given time to address any liquidity risks, suggesting that as of FY 2022 the company held $31MM in excess cash. Between FY 2022 and FY 2023, Duratec’s cash position we roughly ballpark to be little changed as its impacts from its $9MM spend on its acquisition of Wilson’s, $18MM or more of free cash flow thanks to its negative working capital cycle, and dividend payout ratio of 30-50% which at the high end would be an outflow of $9MM would net each other out. Therefore, we arrive at an estimate of $31MM in excess cash at FY 2023 year end.
Taking these together, we arrive at a market cap net of excess cash of $108MM which implies a 21% Owner’s Earnings yield, P/E of 6.0x, and EV/EBIT of 4.4x.
It should also be noted that Duratec’s guidance for FY 2023 may prove to be conservative. The company is likely following the advice of its broker who had advised Duratec to follow the standard playbook of issuing conservative guidance this past November, upgrading that guidance in March, and then delivering or beating those earnings at fiscal year end.
Deep Discount to Peers
Duratec’s most similar publicly traded peers include Australian E&C companies Monadelphous Group, SRG Global, and Saunders International. Each competitor to varying degrees has exposure to asset remediation, but each derives 50% or more of its revenues from construction.
Duratec’s lowest valued peer is Saunders International, which has a similarly strong growth profile and similar market cap. Saunders International net of estimated excess cash currently trades at a FY23E consensus P/E of 9.2x and EV/EBIT of 6.4x.
Duratec’s highest valued peer is Monadelphous Global, which competes with Duratec in mining asset remediation and has a market cap of AUD $1.3B. Monadelphous Global net of estimated excess cash currently trades at a FY23E consensus P/E of 19.8x and EV/EBIT of 13.3x. Relatedly, Monadelphous’ management recently issued an internal memo to no longer subcontract work to Duratec “ever again.” We can only speculate that this could be a reaction to Duratec recently winning mining contracts with BHP and Rio Tinto over Monadelphous. Generally speaking, we take this as a positive sign of Duratec as a growing threat to much larger industry incumbent and competitor Monadelphous.
Duratec, despite arguably having the highest quality business among the group and demonstrating consistent growth ex-COVID, is currently at the short end of a large peer valuation gap. Should Duratec execute on its FY 2023 targets and forecast continued growth, we believe there is a decent or better probability that not only should earnings growth lead to share price appreciation but market participants could begin to take notice of Duratec.
Lack of Discovery
We believe this opportunity exists chiefly due to classic lack of discovery among the investment community.
When I first attempted to get in touch with Duratec several months ago, I was unable to find any email address or investor relations contact information on their website, and ended up finding a contact through an old press release. When I eventually got in touch with Duratec, I was told that I was the second U.S. investor that has reached out to them, which suggests that outside of the Australia and New Zealand investment community, there is a good chance very few investors have yet come across Duratec. At the moment, Duratec is covered by just two sell-side firms.
Duratec also screens poorly at the moment due to its poor 1H 2022 results. As discussed, this was in large part the result of COVID lockdowns delaying project completions. Based on the company’s FY 2023 forecasts, there is good reason to believes that its 1H 2023 results will deliver far greater sales and profits than its 1H 2022 results. These results, when published in February, should improve Duratec’s trailing-twelve-month metrics and much better reflect its current earnings power.
Key Risks
2 show sort by |
Are you sure you want to close this position Duratec Limited?
By closing position, I’m notifying VIC Members that at today’s market price, I no longer am recommending this position.
Are you sure you want to Flag this idea Duratec Limited for removal?
Flagging an idea indicates that the idea does not meet the standards of the club and you believe it should be removed from the site. Once a threshold has been reached the idea will be removed.
You currently do not have message posting privilages, there are 1 way you can get the privilage.
Apply for or reactivate your full membership
You can apply for full membership by submitting an investment idea of your own. Or if you are in reactivation status, you need to reactivate your full membership.
What is wrong with message, "".